login   |    register

Scale Modeling Sponsors

See Your Ad Here!

AK Interactive [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEB SITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

Book Review
11
1945 German Colors
Camouflage Profile Guide
  • move

by: Matt Flegal [ NINJRK ]


Originally published on:
Armorama

introduction

Even if you're not a modeller of German WW2 armour, who doesn't like the colourful and varied camouflage schemes they dreamed up? When other armies were breaking up the monotony of overall green by the thrilling applications of brown or black the Germans were experimenting with a huge variety of patterns and colours that have both enticed and frustrated modellers for decades. AK Interactive have stepped in and given us a book on the camouflage schemes by and for artists.

the book

Why artists? Well, this is not a book that will tell you the history of German paint schemes. Nor will it go into systemic detail on what common schemes came from which units or factories, though some of that information is buried in the captions with each picture. It is not filled with period photos, some B&W, some original colour (and isn't that a can o' worms!), some colourised. What AK Interactive has given you is a book full of 142 gorgeous colour side views of German vehicles as well as 27 more plates of hypothetical "1946" vehicles. Each photo has a caption that gives relevant information; sometimes this includes unit and date but always covers the paints used.

Since the profiles are the core of the book some more information might be in order. First off, the pictures are extremely well done, probably the best I've seen with the caveat that they are shadowed and in many cases weathered or dusted (but no rust). What this means is that you get a very nice reference for shadowing and modulation but the colours have been altered from a pure paint chip. It makes them inspirational but you'll want to refer to the paint chips provided on page three. Those paint chips have a chip for generic shadow and highlight for each of these base colours as well. I pulled a sub-set of 12 random photos to check for other interpretations or reference photos since I believe in trust but verify!. I found five photos (two colour), four other interpretations from other references, and rest assured I didn't find anything. The last is not a criticism as I didn't spend hours scouring my references so I am willing to assume that they exist and were used. I am willing to assume that because what I did find they matched exactly. By exactly I mean if the photo had the tank damaged, the painting mirrored it. The awesome photo of the halftrack in various shades of brown (one of my all time favorite camo schemes) that I compared is carefully mirrored brush stroke for brushstroke.

The ranges of camouflage portrayed is fairly extensive and it seems care was taken to focus on as many different patterns as possible. There are only two winter patterns and they were obviously chosen because they are partial patterns and visually interesting. The 1946 patterns are relatively logical and moderately useful although they are for the most part just standard 1945 camouflage.

Outside of the colour profiles you get two pages describing how they approached interpreting the photos and four pages of models and corresponding plates.

One small thing that is missing from the book is a discussion of primers. They do cover 8012 and a few pictures have the grey gun barrels but one thing that has not been well covered anywhere are the other primers used and what pieces got them and what factories used them. With the emphasis on chipping these days it would be extremely useful to have that information so that black fender components, for example, don't have red primer showing through.

overall

If you want well researched side views of several dozen German AFV's and a few softskins for inspiration and reference this is a really good book. The profiles themselves are easily the prettiest that I've seen, far better than the Squadron Panzer Colours books and even the AJ Press and Wydawnictwo Militaria books. It is almost a coffee table art book in that respect. From a quick double check the schemes appear to be carefully researched and reliable. For the modeller who wants authentic paint schemes to put on their panzers, I'd put this book out there as the one to choose for a one stop reference.

For a historian who wants to know details of where/when/how this isn't the book. Spending a lot more money tracking down the Wydawnictwo Militaria books, the Squadron 3-volume set, and "Wehrmacht Heer Camouflage Colours 1939-1945" (good luck on the last) will give you that to a degree. The captions in this book will give you some of that information, at least for that specific referenced vehicle. However, the book even calls itself a "Camouflage Profile Guide" so it's not targeting that area.

final thoughts


We need a comprehensive book on German paint schemes, especially late war. I would plead with AK Interactive to write that book. It's obvious they have the information and the knowledge base to tap into and it would make a great companion piece to this book. However, this book does exactly what it sets out to do and provides the highest quality art I've seen for this type of book. On an informal note; after flipping through this book I wanted to get more panzer models because there were at least a dozen schemes I desperately want to play with using my trusty Badger airbrush. The book inspired me, what more can I ask of it?
SUMMARY
Highs: Excellent artwork Seems well researched and reliable Huge number of reference profiles Quality printing and binding
Lows: Does not cover the camouflage history in much detail Minimal primer discussion
Verdict: Excellent buy and highly inspiring
Percentage Rating
92%
  Scale: 1:1
  Mfg. ID: AK 403-Book
  Suggested Retail: $29.99
  Related Link: 
  PUBLISHED: Dec 06, 2012
  NATIONALITY: Germany
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 90.45%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 91.17%

About Matt Flegal (ninjrk)
FROM: ALABAMA, UNITED STATES

Copyright ©2017 text by Matt Flegal [ NINJRK ]. Images also by copyright holder unless otherwise noted. Opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of Historicus Forma or Silver Star Enterprises. All rights reserved.


Reader Reviews
Do you own this item and want to review it? You can add your review of the item here. Please read the reader review instructions before posting.


Comments

Nice review, Matt. Good work and glad to see this sort of book. While it might ruffle the feathers of some historians to see modelers weighing in on camo colors, the plain fact of the matter is that we don't get a lot of guidance from the photographic record. Just look at how long it has been to gain even moderate acceptance of the duo-camo patterns of EW Panzers? Even now, most kit manufacturers default to solid panzer gray, and a lot of modelers I speak with insist there is no widespread evidence to support a gray-brown combination.
DEC 06, 2012 - 09:17 AM
After reading the review looks like the book is worth a look at least but not exactly what I was expecting...I think that right now there´s enough info to build a solid book on late war schemes and colors. Given that many of the schemes were factory painted and based in official templates a little investigation could have provided enough info for at least several five view plates (Let´s say 234 late, JagdPz 38t, Tiger II, Panther G, StuG III G ...)that could be used as basis by all modellers. Some could consider that strictly sticking to a scheme would made models "boring" or "repetitive" but A. Tello´s 234/4 is a perfect example of 234 late scheme (Both 234/1 and /4)in all details and I´m sure nobody finds it "boring"... Regarding "colors" when we have mostly B&W pictures there will be always discrepancies between modellers, just look how SCW Panzer I are still depicted as Grey even in the most serious and respectable works
DEC 06, 2012 - 09:53 AM
Agreed. For what it is designed to be the book is excellent. However, my plea to them (or anyone at this point) is we need a reference for the boring stuff now. What were the factory specific patterns and what time frame did they cover? Do the same for specific units where possible. And for God's sake, primers! Please cover primers! Did the barrels truly come in there shades of grey based on production? Which fittings didn't get the red primer, or got a different hue? The good piece of this book is that, for 1945 at least, I have everything I need now for side color profiles. There are lots of them here and the artwork is the best I've seen. Now, if they wanted to do follow ups that covered, say, 1939-1941 and 1942-1944 I'd buy them! Matt
DEC 06, 2012 - 12:08 PM
Tip: Just hit enter to submit your reply!
   

What's Your Opinion?


PHOTOS
Click image to enlarge
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move